Google

Thursday, March 03, 2005

More Twists and Turns

Al-Nahar reports that UN-sponsored investigators now have access to satellite footage of the blast on February 14 that killed Rafik Hariri. If indeed this is true, investigators will undoubtedly be able to read the blast signature to tell how the bomb was detonated - from above or below ground. The Lebanese government has maintained from the beginning - rather weakly, I might add - that the blast was caused by a car bomb. However, numerous amateurs and professionals have noticed that characteristics of the blast crater as well as the debris field around the site of the explosion pointed perhaps more convincingly toward a below-ground explosion (see my previous comments and thread on the issue). A below-ground bomb would have required a larger personnel pool to facilitate, not to mention a very high level of organization and more funds.

The thing that I find really odd is how quickly the Lebanese interior ministry lost control of the situation from the beginning. An investigation allegedly started, but then never materialized. The prime minister requested Swiss investigators as a means to avoid United Nations involvement in an investigation, seeing that the United States already had Kofi Annon on board regarding demands to get Syria out of Lebanon. The prime minister was rebuffed by Switzerland. Meanwhile, the interior ministry paid so little attention to the situation on the ground that they failed to do a full rescue operation following the blast in the first place. Bodies went missing, and the interior ministry refused to facilitate a search. Amid charges of a cover-up of involvement in Hariri's murder, the government did amazingly little to protect itself. So, as as Tony points out at Across the Bay, it is easy to see why the opposition here seeks the resignation of all six security chiefs (both military and civilian) - either the culpability or the competence of the security services needs to be established.

Meanwhile, U.S. Ambassador to Lebanon Jeffrey Feltman attended the public funeral today of Mohammed Ghalayni, one of the missing persons mentioned above whose body was recently recovered. Consider this to be a statement of U.S. support for opposition demands regarding the security chiefs - ambassadors here tend to measure their every action against the politically charged local environment, and this is how many Lebanese would have interpreted his actions anyway.

On a separate but related note, the rumors of the day come from Stratfor's Geopolitical Diary. First off, local magic eight-balls predict that Saudi Arabia will buy Syria's way out of Lebanon:

Assad, bereft of friends, is in Riyadh to see if he can salvage some cash from the debacle. He is at least guaranteed a hearing: The House of Saud also is feeling plenty isolated these days, what with the United States forcing Riyadh into a showdown with its local militants and the Iraqi insurgency raising the frightening possibility of deep Iranian influence across the border in southern -- Shiite-dominated -- Iraq. It might just be in Riyadh's calculus to purchase a future favor from Syria, and Syria has come asking.

But if some of the more colorful rumors are true, then al Assad should not expect to get too much cash. According to the Middle East rumor mill, the late Rafik al-Hariri was the illegitimate son of none other than Saudi King Fahd. It was Saudi mediation that helped put al-Hariri in charge after the Lebanese civil war ended, and Saudi money was critical in the reconstruction effort.

This second rumor has been around a long time, and it was most likely started by some of Hariri's enemies, but there is no doubt that Hariri was a "favorite son" (no pun intended) of the house of Saud. Regardless, the situation is thus: Hariri is dead. The Lebanese are extremely restless now, and they are demonstrating lots of ideas about freedom of assembly and political self-determination that many leaders in the Middle East find less than comfortable, not to mention that the Saudi royal family really liked Hariri the way he was - still alive. Hence, Assad is now in Saudi Arabia, where all the money is, very much vulnerable to bribes and whatever else may be on the agenda. The next few days should be very interesting indeed.

5 Comments:

At 11:21 PM, March 03, 2005, Blogger jp said...

"There is considerable inertia not just within Syria, but also within the hearts of the Lebanese people. Syria plays dirty, and they play to win, and more recently they have been doing so with increasing recklessness."
Appreciate your comments on my blog http://www.americansforfreedom.blogspot.com/. i am starting to understand why the Lebanese people would be hesitant to stand up, after so long, but recent days have proven that this hesitancy has fallen away. Also, I think Bush, with Chirac, et all have also demonstrated that they will not let Syria get away with any tomfoolery this time. I predict Syria is out within months, and even Assad could be gone by the end of the year.

 
At 2:25 AM, March 04, 2005, Blogger Unfrozen Caveman Linguist said...

First, let's understand why the Lebanese people were able to "stand up," so to speak. Lebanon already has significant manifestations of "people power" - democratic institutions, a vibrant civil society, and a free and independent media. Also, Lebanon has the highest literacy rate in the entire Middle East, and there exist more universities here than in ALL the remaining countries in the middle east combined. The opposition movement that got worldwide attention for itself would never be possible in any other country in the Middle East, least of all Syria, which has one of the lowest literacy rates on earth and an extremely poor economy to boot. An opposition movement there, at least one based on secular democratic principles, stands little chance under the current circumstances. Surely the Bush administration understands this, or at least I hope so. If Assad is to be "gone by the end of the year," as you say, then it will require a completely different set of tactics, along with the requisite understanding that Syria, with no democratic institutions, civil society, or free press like Lebanon has, can very easily fall into chaos. The Assad dynasty has been sitting on a boiling cauldron of Islamist tension for decades; the government of Omar Karami in Lebanon was not (at least not by comparison). Getting rid of Assad under such circumstances is so risky that it certainly cannot be considered seriously, unless the U.S. is prepared to go the distance and put the remainder of its military there to keep the peace.

Second, Assad was just in Saudi Arabia, probably making deals with the royal family in order to save face. More than anyone in the region, the House of Saud wants to see the demonstrations in Lebanon cool off, because this kind of thing gives people ideas. In short, while I do believe that increased "people power" in this region is indeed coming eventually, one should guard against considering Lebanon as just another fallen domino. Lebanon is, after all, a unique case in this part of the world.

 
At 2:43 PM, March 04, 2005, Blogger David B. said...

Thanks for your posts on Lebanon. You are an invaluable resource to those of us who want to follow the situation in Lebanon, but who can't get enough news in the mainstream media.

Keep up the good work!

 
At 9:01 AM, March 05, 2005, Anonymous Anonymous said...

Historically, uprisings have failed when the West stood by and did nothing so as to not shake the status quo (Hungary, Prague, Tien An Men Square, etc.) The ones that succeed are the ones that have a lot of external support and I believe that situation applies to Lebanon. When you have the U.S., France, Russia, Saudi Arabia and others mobilizing against Syria, there is an implied willingness (at least with the U.S.) to go beyond rhetoric and apply sanctions and force to support the Lebanese.

The genie is out of the bottle in Lebanon and the law of unintended consequences is changing things so fast nobody knows where what will happen with any certainty. But one consequence is that Syria will definitely be forced to leave Lebanon, and Assad will then have a difficult time holding on to power in Syria.

And Lebanon will be free to manage its own affairs, which all acknowledge will not be easy. But you now have support from the world. Please do not underestimate the power of that support on the momentum for change in Lebanon's favor.

 
At 2:42 PM, March 05, 2005, Blogger liminal said...

I heard from friends in Lebanon that there was a sewage tunnel (or something to that affect)...you know, italian job style. And they took trucks underneath the street filled with explosives. Maybe the same explosives you spoke of in your latest post. Then they used a hard-wire system as they knew Hariri had not one but two (yes, a backup) systems to detect mobile detonated devices. The same kind of device Hariri gave Jumblatt.

 

Post a Comment

Links to this post:

Create a Link

<< Home